All terrain tire recommendations?

Awesome! I love that Blue exterior, and the avatar

 

I've used General Grabber AT2’s and Goodyear DuraTrac's (265-70-17). I have a steep mountain rock covered driveway at 3800' elevation, and both do very well off road and in deep snow.

 

I just switched from the OEM Bridgestones to KO2's on my '19 TRD ORP. Only road driving so far but no complaints. No extra noise that I have noticed and they certainly look better.

 

Sorry TRD in PDX, just noticed this question! I like Duratracs, I had them on a 2015 Tacoma as a summer tire. They worked great off road, and were respectable at highway speeds, not unduly noisy. A big part of large luggy tires is to keep them aligned and balanced, especially aligned. If you're driving off road, you bump and crawl over obstacles and its easy to get misaligned. Then once you get a little cupping on your tires, sometimes not even visually noticeable - they get noisy. You'll see common complaints on here that such and such tire like a BFG or Duratrac is noisy when basically they're pretty quiet. A lot of guys cheap out on alignments, I get it, you don't see it, like you do when you put on an accessory like a new light bar or some sliders. But being religious about alignments goes along with being off road, and it makes a difference, especially at highway speeds.